Free senior care guidance for Indianapolis-area families. No cost to you, ever.
Call (463) 208-0977
Indy Senior AdvisorPeople • Places • Possibilities

Choosing Between Two Communities

The questions that break a tie once the tours all start blurring together.

Home›Comparisons›Choosing Between Two Communities
Short answer

When two communities both seem workable, compare the all-in cost at your parent's actual care level, the three-year rate increase history, overnight staffing (not daytime), both facilities' state inspection records, and whether either holds a Medicaid waiver provider agreement your family might eventually need.

This decision comes up often enough that we cover it in full, with a step-by-step comparison process, on its own page in our situations section rather than repeating it here.

See the full comparison walkthrough →

What to ask on a tour. Ask to see the state inspection report, the memory-care disclosure/certification if marketed, the all-in cost at your parent's care level, the three-year rate increase history, and the overnight staffing ratio. Read the full explanation →

Questions families ask

What does assisted living cost in Indianapolis?

The CareScout Cost of Care Survey publishes a statewide Indiana median only -- $5,639 a month for a private one-bedroom in 2025 -- not an Indianapolis-specific figure. Local pricing likely differs from the state median in either direction; ask each community for its current rate.

What does memory care cost in Indiana?

There is no published memory-care median for Indiana or any other state -- CareScout does not survey it as a category. Any memory-care price you see quoted online is an estimate or an extrapolation, not a sourced figure. Get quotes in writing from each community instead.

What does a nursing home cost in Indiana?

CareScout's 2025 survey puts Indiana's nursing home median at $8,943 a month for a semi-private room and $10,326 for a private room. Semi-private figures are often Medicaid-weighted and lower than a private-pay quote you'd actually be offered.

What does in-home care cost in Indiana, and when does a community become cheaper?

Indiana's 2025 CareScout median for non-medical home care is $35 an hour. A 40-hour week already runs about $6,067 a month, above Indiana's assisted living median -- so once care needs push past roughly 40 hours a week, it is worth running the math against a community's monthly rate.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in your area that actually fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find senior care — free